Home    |    Camp + Schools    |    Subscribe    |    Advertise    |    Contact    |   Search  
JCRC Candidate Questionnare
Mishmash
Jewish World
Beltway
Sports
Mideast Report
Local News
National
Mideast
InFocus
Obits
International
10/21/2009 8:59:00 PM Email this articlePrint this article 
McDonnell leads in reputed bellwether contest
by Richard Greenberg

Associate Editor

If the Virginia gubernatorial race is indeed a referendum on President Barack Obama, as some claim, it may also be a litmus test of where voters stand ideologically.

Local Jews can be found at both ends of the political spectrum, although they tend to skew liberal. Those who lean to the right, however, said in interviews that they support Republican candidate Robert McDonnell, the commonwealth's former attorney general, for his staunchly conservative positions on fiscal and social issues, including some stances that have outraged Jews who lean the other way.

However, his emphasis on job creation and holding the line on taxes has also drawn support from pro-business moderates.

McDonnell is running against Democratic state Sen. Creigh Deeds of rural Bath County, who has lagged in the polls throughout the race, and trailed by 9 percentage points, according to an Oct. 8 survey conducted by The Washington Post.

The campaign has focused largely on two sets of issues. One: culture-war topics that resonate strongly with Jews, such as abortion, homosexuality and the propriety of women in the workforce. Two: Virginia's economic crisis and transportation woes - as well as the candidates' experience and other qualifications for office.

Social issues, which have generated considerable controversy during the campaign, may have galvanized segments of the Virginia Jewish community, according to Linda Berg, political director of the National Jewish Democratic Council. "They're wedge issues, too, and they really could have an impact, especially among women voters," she explained, drawing on anecdotal information. "There's such a stark contrast between the two candidates."

McDonnnell staked out reliably conservative positions on several issues raised in a recent candidates' questionnaire produced by the Jewish Community Relations Council. He said he is "pro-life," supports the death penalty, and opposes local ordinances that "attempt to discourage gun ownership."

McDonnell's conservatism became a major issue when the campaign erupted in late August over the candidate's 1989 college graduate thesis (titled "The Republican Party's Vision for the Family"), in which he described working women as "detrimental" to the traditional family, lamented the "purging" of religion from public schools, criticized a U.S. Supreme Court decision legalizing contraception for unmarried couples and referred to gays as "fornicators."

McDonnell, 55, was blasted by Democrats, including many Jews, who said the thesis demonstrated that he was out of touch ideologically with much of the Virginia electorate, and had in fact adopted positions reflecting that disparity while he was attorney general.

Early this year, for example, shortly before McDonnell resigned as attorney general to focus on his gubernatorial bid, he endorsed the constitutionality of controversial church-state legislation that was strongly opposed by both the JCRC and the American Civil Liberties Union.

The measure would have permitted state police chaplains in Virginia to offer denominational prayers at official events.

In his damage-control campaign following the leak about his thesis, McDonnell emphasized that many of his views have evolved since his grad school days, as indicated in part by his hiring and promotion of female employees.

"I have a record of governing and managing that reflects strong support for working women," he said last week in an interview with WJW.

"This is an act of desperation on the part of the Democrats; they're trying to solidify their support on the left," added Larry Krakover, 61, a GOP organizer from Burke. "This is a 20-year-old thesis they're talking about. It's much ado about nothing."

Ron Halber, executive director of the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Washington, said the thesis bombshell was probably dropped too early to cause substantive damage to McDonnell on election day, Nov. 3.

"A lot of it seems to have lost its shelf life," he said.

Both McDonnell and Deeds have said they are staunch backers of the Virginia Israel Advisory Board, which seeks to spur economic growth by forging stronger ties between the commonwealth and the Jewish state.

The board, however, has incurred substantial budget cuts recently, and both candidates have called for increased funding, according to the JCRC questionnaire.

In some of his other responses to the questionnaire, McDonnell said he is a "vigorous supporter of religious liberty" on church-state matters, favors divestment aimed at stanching state-sponsored terrorism and opposes "federal health care reform" because it "could jeopardize access to quality affordable health care."

McDonnell has outlined a 12-point program to improve transportation in Virginia, but Deeds has failed to produce a substantive plan, and in general has been unable to articulate his positions on several key matters, according to McDonnell backers. "I don't see that as effective leadership," said Kaplan.

On the other hand, some Democrats have questioned the viability of McDonnell's proposals. " "No new taxes' is disingenuous," said Dottie Bennett, 68, a self-described left-leaning, independent political activist from Falls Church, who is also uncomfortable with McDonnell's take on social issues. "You can't be no-tax-increase and still move the state forward."

Regarding McDonnell's qualifications to serve as governor, Republican activist Jim Kaplan of Fairfax said, "Bob brings a wealth of experience to the job at the executive level."

In addition to heading the attorney general's office, Iraq war veteran McDonnell was a lieutenant colonel in the Army and business manager for the American Hospital Supply Company, a Fortune 500 company. He also served for 14 years in the Virginia House of Delegates.

Vying for voters in Virginia
Deeds down in polls, but Jews rally behind him
by Adam Kredo

Staff Writer

For Democratic activist Steve Stone, an aura of "negative pessimism" shrouds the Virginia gubernatorial race.

A loyal supporter of Democratic candidate Sen. Creigh Deeds -- who, according to recent polls, sags nearly 10 points behind his Republican opponent, Robert McDonnell -- Stone admits that "the Democrats are in big trouble."

Yet that bleak assessment hasn't dampened the Fairfax resident's stalwart support for Deeds, a candidate he and many other Jews laud as a centrist lawmaker with the political chops to rescue Virginia from the brink of fiscal collapse.

"He's probably one of the most moderate candidates" the Democrats have selected in recent memory, said Debra Steppel, a Deeds supporter from Reston, who praised the candidate for his ability to distill a policy debate down to "what's best for the Virginia citizenry overall."

Issues such as the economy and a soaring rate of unemployment have received top billing throughout the race, but Jewish Democrats maintain that Deeds' stance on social issues -- such as reproductive choice and the separation of church and state -- could cement a come-from-behind victory.

Deeds supports a woman's right to choose, and voted against a bill allowing sectarian prayer at public events.

"When it comes to social views," McDonnell, on the other hand, is "far from the mainstream," Stone said, citing the former attorney general's deeply conservative views on abortion, an issue that commonly rouses liberal Jews.

Steppel, too, fears that the Republican would use his pulpit in Richmond to "push his [conservative social] agenda on everyone in Virginia."

In lieu of his controversial 1989 graduate school thesis -- an essay that characterized working women as "detrimental" to the traditional family -- Steppel said that McDonnell "does not seem to me to be the kind of politician Jewish women would" tend to back. Deeds, she added, has a "strong ethical compass."

Supporters, however, appear to be engaged in an uphill battle to overtake McDonnell, who, according to an Oct. 9 poll in The Washington Post, has made significant in-roads with voters in the traditionally liberal stomping grounds of Northern Virginia.

For his part, however, Deeds says he's fine with being called an underdog.

"I've been running as an underdog all my life," Deeds, 51, said Tuesday in an interview with WJW. "I lived in a trailer when I was a kid. I've been an underdog in nearly every election I've run, and I've managed to persevere."

And there is much to persevere against these days as the race winds to a finish, Deeds said, accusing his rival of waging a no-holds-barred advertising blitz to taint his reputation among voters. "All [McDonnell] knows how to do is attack."

Bad blood, however, has flowed both ways, with each candidate broadcasting a flurry of negative ads.

Asked why he's focused so much time and energy discussing McDonnell's 1989 thesis, Deeds said: "I've talked about social issues in this election because I think it helps explain why Bob McDonnell has never been focused on jobs until this election. He's never wrote a bill to create a job or expand an educational opportunity," but has instead authored legislation aiming to restrict a women's reproductive rights.

Yet some voters have grown weary of hearing about the thesis, saying that the ongoing ad blitz demonstrates a lack of substantive policy goals on Deeds' part.

"At first it did have an effect, but that has waned," said Shari Simmans Bolouri, a Republican foot soldier from Alexandria, who described the continued onslaught of negativity from Deeds' camp as "the tactic of a desperate campaign."

Policy-wise, McDonnell has blasted Deeds over the looming issues of transportation and economic revitalization. Right-leaning Jews also faulted the Democrat on similar fronts.

"He doesn't have a plan" to tackle the state's transportation issues, said Bolouri, dismissing Deeds' proposal to establish a bipartisan transportation committee after election day. The establishment of a panel, she argued, hardly amounts to much of a plan.

Yet, Deeds labels his tactic the most viable and "honest approach to transportation" available.

"I'm using the only appropriate [solution] to transportation that's worked in the last 30 years," Deeds said. "It involves more than just bringing people together. It's going to take leadership to bring the right people together and develop the right plan."

Certain guidelines will frame the discussion, Deeds said, explaining that he will push for a plan that is "long-term in scope," tackles issues on a statewide basis (rather than pitting "one part of the state against another") and is "creative" in nature. Pushed for further details, Deeds said that one possible solution to reduce traffic congestion would be to offer tax credits to entice commuters into taking public transportation.

On the economic front, Deeds emphasized the importance of the Virginia Israel Advisory Board, a state board that works to lure Israeli companies into Virginia. Though VIAB has faced significant budget cuts since the recession began, Deeds maintains that "the alliance we have with Israel is absolutely critical to our economic expansion."

This fact became abundantly clear to the veteran lawmaker during his first trip to the Jewish state in December.

"I came away really with an understanding of how we can invest economically" in the technology sector, Deeds said of the trip, which was sponsored by the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Washington. "There's capital and ideas in Israel that I think can benefit the economy of Virginia."

If elected, Deeds said he would work to increase VIAB's funding, as the board serves as an "important conduit" between Israel and Virginia.

Deeds also said he would support legislation mandating that the state divest from countries backing terrorists, such as Sudan and Iran -- at least in theory. The hypothetical divestment bill, he said, would have to be "constitutional" and meet "all the muster that I thought was appropriate." If the bill were up to par, he continued, "I would certainly consider, and probably, [sign it]."

Jerome Chapman, a Democrat from Alexandria, expressed confidence that Deeds' "honesty and straight talk" will ultimately resonate with voters. While political expediency often scores quick points with voters, Chapman praised Deeds for being above the partisan scrum.

Case in point: the JCRC's last Jewish Advocacy Day, where Chapman lobbied Deeds to vote against a controversial piece of legislation that would have permitted sectarian prayer at public events.

"I talked to him about it and he said, 'If I vote against it, I could get in trouble,' " likely with more conservative voters, Chapman recalled.

Following that chat, the bill was defeated in committee, thanks in large part to Deeds' decision to vote against the measure.

"I've seen him do this over and over again," Chapman said. "He understands that certain actions may be more popular [with voters], but he consistently votes based on what he believes is right and not necessarily popular."

Related Stories:
• Wagner brings nonprofit perspective to candidacy
• Playing the anti-Israel card?Mideast is shoehorned into Va. governor's race
• Jewish outreach across Va.
• Bolling and McDonnell are on the same page



Article Comment Submission Form
Please feel free to submit your comments.

Article comments are not posted immediately to the website. Each submission must be approved by the website editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission.

Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number is for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.

Name:
Telephone:
E-mail:
Passcode: This form will not send your comment unless you copy exactly the passcode seen below into the text field. This is an anti-spam device to help reduce the automated email spam coming through this form.

Please copy the passcode exactly
- it is case sensitive.
Message:
May your comment appear as a letter to the editor in the print edition, provided it is 300 words or fewer?
   




disclaimers | about us | privacy policy
Copyright 2010, Washington Jewish Week
11426 Rockville Pike Suite 236, Rockville, MD 20852
(301) 230-2222
Software © 1998-2010 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved