
There are moments when decency requires very little. Oct. 7 was one of them.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani did not have to endorse Israel’s government. He did not have to defend the Gaza war. He did not have to retreat from a single political position he has taken about Palestinians or American policy. He simply had to recognize what Oct. 7 means to Jews.
He could not do it.
In his statement marking the third anniversary of the Hamas massacre, Mamdani acknowledged that “Hamas killed more than 1,100 Israelis and abducted 251 others.” He said New Yorkers carried “unthinkable loss.” And then, almost immediately, he turned a day commemorating the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust into another indictment of Israel.
“The suffering did not begin nor end that day,” he declared, before accusing Israel of “ongoing genocide,” “occupation and apartheid” and repeated war crimes. He accused the United States of complicity and invoked Palestinian children, ambulances, journalists and blocked food shipments.
Those subjects can be debated. Oct. 7 was not the day for the mayor of the city with the largest Jewish population outside Israel to use Jewish mourning as the preface to that debate.
The Anti-Defamation League put it well: Mamdani was “weaponizing a day meant for mourning.” It also noted something extraordinary: He never once used the word “Jews.” That omission matters.
Oct. 7 was not an abstraction. Hamas terrorists slaughtered families, murdered young people at a music festival, committed sexual violence and dragged men, women and children into Gaza. Jews around the world experienced the attack as an assault on them as well. A mayor does not need to share that trauma. But the mayor of New York City has an obligation to understand it.
Mamdani has defended his approach as one of “universality,” insisting that humanity cannot pick and choose whose suffering matters. Fine. But universality does not require hijacking one community’s day of mourning to lecture it about another community’s suffering. Compassion is not a zero-sum exercise.
And this was not an inexperienced politician stumbling over an exquisitely sensitive moment. Mamdani issued a strikingly similar Oct. 7 statement last year, mourning Hamas’ victims before pivoting to accusations against Israel. He knew how such a statement would be received. He chose essentially the same approach again.
Jewish New Yorkers do not need Zohran Mamdani’s sympathy. They do not need him to become a Zionist, defend Benjamin Netanyahu or abandon his concern for Palestinians. But they have every right to expect something more elementary from their mayor: honesty about what happened on Oct. 7 and enough humanity to allow its victims one day of unqualified remembrance.
Instead, Mamdani gave them a political argument dressed up as a condolence message.
Perhaps he thought he was demonstrating moral consistency. But what he actually demonstrated was an inability — or unwillingness — to let murdered Jews occupy the center of the story even on the anniversary of their murder.
If that was the best the mayor of New York City could offer on Oct. 7, he would have been better off saying nothing. Silence, at least, would not have pretended to be compassion.


