Opinion: When Accusation Becomes Verdict

0
Rachel Szor and Yuval Abraham, the directors of “Naza,” at the 83rd Venice International Film Festival in Venice, Italy.
Rachel Szor and Yuval Abraham, the directors of “Naza,” at the 83rd Venice International Film Festival in Venice, Italy. (Photo credit: wikicommons/LucaFazPhoto)

David J. ButlerThe controversy over “NAZA” is being argued in familiar terms. Supporters see a devastating expose of Israeli conduct in Gaza. Critics see a tendentious documentary built around anonymous witnesses, questionable sourcing and conclusions the evidence cannot sustain.

But there is a more important issue underneath that argument. When does testimony become evidence? And when does evidence become verdict?

“NAZA,” directed by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, presents testimony from 24 anonymous Israeli military and intelligence personnel describing targeting systems, artificial intelligence, civilian casualty calculations and Israeli conduct during the Gaza war. Its allegations have since been treated in some quarters not simply as claims demanding investigation, but as an authoritative account of what Israel did and why. That transformation deserves scrutiny.

One of the film’s most shocking allegations is that a strike was once approved despite an anticipated civilian death toll of 500 people for a single target. Yet a detailed Times of Israel examination found that the documentary offers only one anonymous interviewee for that claim, provides no supporting documentation and gives viewers little information enabling them to assess the source’s position or firsthand knowledge. None of that proves the allegation false. But neither does putting it on a movie screen prove it true.

The power of “NAZA” comes partly from accumulated signals of authority. The witnesses are insiders. Their identities are concealed because, we are told, they risk consequences for speaking. The film wins an important prize. Critics praise it. Audiences applaud it.

Each fact may legitimately increase our interest in what the film uncovered. Together, however, they can create the impression that somebody else has already done the hard work of verification for us.

That is where a documentary can make an accusation feel adjudicated without actually subjecting it to adjudication.
Documentaries are powerful because they tell stories. They choose witnesses, arrange testimony, juxtapose images and lead audiences toward conclusions. Filmmaking is an act of selection, and selection is not neutral.

The viewer has to distinguish between evidence presented in a documentary and the documentary’s interpretation of that evidence. The two can merge easily when the audience has no independent way to evaluate the sources.

“NAZA” makes that problem especially acute because its principal witnesses cannot be independently assessed by the viewer. Anonymity may be justified; whistleblowers sometimes cannot speak otherwise. But we do not know a source’s rank, proximity to the decision described, whether others disagreed, or whether an incident reflected policy, aberration or misunderstanding.

The filmmakers say they verified their sources and allegations. Perhaps they did. But when neither the sources nor much of the corroborating material can be examined, viewers are ultimately being asked to trust the filmmakers’ verification of testimony they cannot evaluate themselves.

The Israeli response has hardly improved matters. Threats to revoke the filmmakers’ citizenship and accusations of treason merely substitute another form of authority: believe the government because the government says the film is outrageous.
The answer to questionable authority is not competing authority. It is contestable evidence.

If “NAZA” claims a targeting practice existed, what evidence establishes it? If an interviewee describes an extraordinary civilian-casualty threshold, what corroborates that account? If the IDF says a claim is false, what can it responsibly disclose? When security considerations prevent public disclosure, can trusted independent investigators examine the underlying material?

The standard should apply in every direction. A film festival jury is not a commission of inquiry. A whistleblower is not automatically a disinterested fact-finder. A military spokesman is not an independent investigator. And applause — whether in Venice or Jerusalem — is not evidence.

We increasingly live in an environment in which information arrives pre-certified. A credentialed expert says it. A former intelligence officer confirms it. A respected institution endorses it. A viral video appears to show it. A documentary wins an award.

We are repeatedly invited to outsource judgment. Modern life depends upon experts, institutions and journalists. But trust cannot mean surrender.

The obligation of serious journalism is to show us not merely what its sources believe, but why we should believe them. The obligation of a democratic government is to produce as much verifiable evidence as security permits. And citizens must remain capable of holding two ideas simultaneously: disturbing testimony may reveal something terribly important, and disturbing testimony is not automatically proof.

Its admirers need not choose between believing every allegation and ignoring Palestinian suffering. Its opponents need not choose between defending Israel and asking whether serious wrongdoing occurred.

Israel already permits that scrutiny. Journalists challenge official accounts, courts review government conduct, and military decisions can be investigated and criticized. The problem is not that inquiry is forbidden. It is that inquiry usually arrives second.

By then the accusation has framed the issue, selected the evidence and shaped the audience’s first impression. The accused is left explaining, rebutting and supplying context inside somebody else’s narrative. That is the frustration “NAZA” exposes. Not that Israel cannot answer serious allegations, but that it is almost always answering from behind.

There is no perfect cure for that asymmetry. But there is a better response: greater transparency before controversies erupt, faster disclosure when they do, and independent scrutiny credible enough that the public need not choose simply between trusting filmmakers and trusting governments.

The danger is not inquiry. Inquiry is essential. The danger is allowing accusation to acquire the authority of a verdict before inquiry has had a fair chance to begin.

David J. Butler is an attorney. He is president of Dvash Consulting, LLC and a member of the ownership group of Mid-Atlantic Media, which owns and publishes Washington Jewish Week.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here